TNB Night Owl – Canadian Magic

Ten string guitar. Image captured by the News Blender.

Gordon Lightfoot and Anne Murray could have had a genre all to themselves for melodious voices from Canada whose music appealed to a wide audience. Their styles have been categorized variously as folk, folk-pop, folk-rock, country, and adult contemporary. Clearly, they both always had a good deal of crossover magnetism.

Murray released Cotton Jenny as a single a year after Lightfoot released it on his album Summer Side of Life in 1971. For some reason, although I remember his version vividly, I can’t recall ever hearing her version before even though it charted well and appears to have been the more successful of the two. Still, I like his version better. Both are listed below, back-to-back, so you can compare them for yourselves.

Note that Anne Murray had a bunch of other hits from 1978 on through the 1980s – this playlist stops early in the interest of time and space, but also to more evenly match up “his and hers” hits from a single era.

1970
If You Could Read My Mind (3:49)
Gordon Lightfoot

1970
Snowbird (2:18)
Anne Murray

1971
Cotton Jenny (3:24)
Gordon Lightfoot

1972
Cotton Jenny (3:00)
Anne Murray

1972
Danny’s Song (3:09)
Anne Murray

1974
Sundown (3:33)
Gordon Lightfoot

1973
A Love Song (2;50)
Anne Murray

1974
Carefree Highway (3:43)
Gordon Lightfoot

1974
You Won’t See Me (4:07)
Anne Murray

1975
Rainy Day People (2:49)
Gordon Lightfoot

1976
The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald (5:58)
Gordon Lightfoot

About the opinions in this article…

Any opinions expressed in this article are the opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of this website or of the other authors/contributors who write for it.

About Richard Doud 622 Articles
Learning is a life-long endeavor. Never stop learning. No one is right all the time. No one is wrong all the time. No exceptions to these rules.